RSS

What Jesus Said on Homosexuality

03 Jan

10298943_202448230099115_7105373244802606819_n This image has been doing the rounds on social media lately. It isn’t bad, and makes a great starting point for a dialogue about rights for homosexual Christians. Unfortunately it is not a complete argument. Quoting this to Christians who know their New Testament and want to argue that God opposes homosexuality will get you into a tight spot fairly quickly, and not in a good way.

While Jesus himself says nothing on the topic (not strictly true but let’s roll with it), the apostle Paul does seem to say a fair bit. In what is arguably the first book of the New Testament in terms of date of authorship Paul pretty much opens with a story about an arrogant city who God destroyed by making all the straight people gay. It doesn’t list homosexuality itself as their sin but it is a go-to verse for Christians who want to claim that homosexuality and Christianity are mutually exclusive, so it needs to be addressed. Read Romans One carefully and check if it does actually say that it is sinful for people who are naturally homosexual to practice what is natural for them, or does it say something else?

Secondly, Paul claims to be responsible for the doctrine of Gentile Christians not being bound to the Old Testament rules of Mosaic law/lore. The four concessions to complete freedom was that Gentile Christians should abstain from food sacrificed to idols, from blood, from the meat of strangled animals and from sexual immorality. That last one is what people will cling to because it is repeated ALMOST as many times in the New Testament as the command that male believers are to kiss each other on the lips whenever they meet. This is one of those tricky ones because the word that is translated as “sexual immorality” is a word that Paul seems to have made up and doesn’t appear in texts by any other author. The root word means to “sell off” and is contextually linked to the diagrams temple prostitutes would draw to show what activities they were available for within the context of divine sexuality for profit (this was a practice of some of the Roman temples, the Hebrew temple had largely stamped that out but there is biblical evidence that it had been an issue during the Babylonian occupation). It was translated into the more general “sexual immorality” during a time of schism within the church and has a lot of political motivation behind the choice of words.

So that verse can mean one of two things:
1) Don’t eat food sacrificed to other gods, don’t drink blood as part of a worship ritual of other gods, don’t eat animals killed in an inhumane way for purposes of ritual sacrifice to other gods, don’t be gay.
OR
2) Don’t eat food sacrificed to other gods, don’t drink blood as part of a worship ritual of other gods, don’t eat animals killed in an inhumane way for purposes of ritual sacrifice to other gods, don’t participate in ritual prostitution as part of the worship of other gods.

I know that’s a lot to take in, but I think it is important that people are equipped to engage Christians on their own beliefs and ask “does your bible really say that?” with a bit of solid knowledge to back that up.

Advertisements
 
2 Comments

Posted by on January 3, 2016 in Uncategorized

 

2 responses to “What Jesus Said on Homosexuality

  1. Bob

    January 3, 2016 at 11:52 AM

    As always, a very good post. When it comes to challenging and; God forbid, changing the thinking of many Christians it is a difficult task indeed. All to often the issue of homosexuality ( by those who are offended by it) ends up being wrong motives in search of right Bible verses to prove that I am right, purely coincidence of course, and you (if “YOU” happens to mean you don’t have an issue with it and or are pro gay) are wrong.

    Putting this issues aside for one moment, this happens with so many other issues and we seek to disguise our own wrong or misplaced motives by the use of Bible verses used in OUR favour. Jesus called this the ‘pharisaical spirit” and we all know he had some rather strong words to say about this.

    The task is made all the easier because now we have a Bible Concordance and this only encourages a sort of ‘cut-and-paste’ reaction where so often verses are taken out of context because the concordance never encourages Christians to read verses within its original context. The Bible then ends up being used as a sort of ‘weapon’ designed to ‘end’ conversation and not ‘engage’ with them, which is the more difficult task. All the very best and I look forward to reading the responses to this post.

     
  2. Sam

    April 15, 2016 at 7:48 AM

    You mean you look forward to sitting back in your easy chair, sipping some refreshing iced beverage and watching the fundamentalists spew forth fire and brimstone at every tiny tiny microscopic detail like they some sort of theological Lucadores? Yeah…. That’s sounds fun actually! Can I sit next to you Bob? Pass a cold one would you please? Thanks! Here, I brought nachos. Have some.

     

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: